In early April 2025, Gary Friedman, chief executive of RH, explained on an earnings call why his company had just sold a house on Red Mountain instead of building one. The property at 319 Ridge Road had been planned as the "RH Residence on Red Mountain," a furnished six-bedroom home with an infinity pool and views to Aspen Mountain and Independence Pass. According to the Aspen Daily News, Friedman told analysts that construction costs in Aspen had "became prohibited" and a new build "didn't look like a good investment," so the partners chose to sell "this old house."
The house was built in 1982 and remodeled in 1985. A limited liability company controlled by developer Mark Hunt, with RH holding a 70% interest, bought it for $11 million in August 2020 and sold it for $26 million on March 26, 2025, after 639 days on the market. A developer with an announced plan, a design brand and a downtown partner looked at the cost of replacing a 43-year-old house and decided the old house was worth more as it stood.
That decision explains most of what has happened on Red Mountain since. Read one at a time, the neighborhood's recent sales show buyers pricing an older house as a very expensive lot plus the size of the existing frame. Finishes, age and style move the number less than portal medians suggest. What separates a $26 million trade from a $91 million one is mostly how much house already stands on the land, and how much it would cost to replace.
Five Trades on and Around Willoughby Way
The table below lists the Red Mountain transactions in the public record from fall 2024 through spring 2026. The per-square-foot figures are calculated from the reported price and house size.
| Property | House | Lot | Price | When | Approx. per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 848 Willoughby Way | Vacant after 2022 demolition | Not reported | $25M | Fall 2024 | n/a |
| 319 Ridge Road | Built 1982, remodeled 1985 | Not reported | $26M | March 2025 | n/a |
| New spec home, Red Mountain | About 7,200 sq ft, completed March 2025 | Not reported | $37.75M | 2025 | About $5,240 |
| 645 Willoughby Way | Built 1984, 9,170 sq ft | 1.65 acres | $37M | Late May 2026 | About $4,035 |
| 76 Placer Lane | Built around 2012, 13,400 sq ft | 1.7 acres | $91.3M | June 2026 | About $6,810 |
For comparison, Aspen single-family homes sold at an average of $3,274 per square foot from January through September 2026, according to the Aspen Snowmass Sotheby's International Realty Q3 2026 market report. Every Red Mountain house in the table with a reported size cleared that average, including the 1984 house at 645 Willoughby Way, by about $760 a foot.
The Lot Sets the Floor
The vacant parcel at 848 Willoughby Way shows what the land is worth with nothing on it. The Aspen Local traced the parcel through three sales. It closed at $12.1 million in April 2018 and at $14.65 million in November 2018. The 1990s house on it was demolished in 2022, and the empty lot sold for $25 million in fall 2024 to a San Antonio-based LLC, a 70% gain in six years.
Against that $25 million floor, the older houses on the list look different. In March 2025, 319 Ridge Road traded at $26 million with a seven-bedroom house, elevator, three-car garage and caretaker apartment included. Fourteen months later, 645 Willoughby Way traded at $37 million for a 1984 stone-and-shingle house on 1.65 acres, with a pond, a natural stream, a gazebo and an outdoor kitchen. The parcels differ, so the comparison is directional. Still, it puts the premium for an older, well-kept house on Red Mountain somewhere between about $1 million and about $12 million above what bare dirt brought in 2024.
Long holds show the same pattern. The estate of art collector Melva Bucksbaum bought 645 Willoughby Way in 1998 for $8.3 million and sold it in 2026 for $37 million. Andrew Lessman's entity bought 76 Placer Lane for $10.5 million in 2007, built a contemporary house there around 2012, and sold it for $91.3 million, according to The Wall Street Journal. Both owners started with a Red Mountain lot at roughly similar cost basis. The difference in how they exited came down to what each owner had standing on the land at the time of sale.
The Frame Is the Second Layer
Above the lot, buyers are paying for the size of the structure. Writing about Willoughby Way in December 2024, The Aspen Local quoted Dan Popish, chief deputy appraiser at the Pitkin County Assessor's Office, on what owners of the street's large older homes can do with them: "You can gut it to the bones, keep that large home structure, and make it what they want." The same article put most Willoughby Way homes between 5,000 and 10,000 square feet, with a few at 11,000 or 12,000.
The 2026 sales follow size closely. At 13,400 square feet, the house at 76 Placer Lane is the largest in the table, and Byron Allen paid $91.3 million for it. The Wall Street Journal called it one of the priciest deals in the area's history. The Real Deal noted that Aspen's price record still belongs to the $108 million estate Steve Wynn and Thomas Peterffy bought in 2024, which The Aspen Local identified as 419 Willoughby Way. At 9,170 square feet, 645 Willoughby Way is the second-largest house on the list, and its buyer paid for a 1984 house mainly for its size and its 1.65 acres.
The new spec home that sold for $37.75 million in 2025 was about 7,200 square feet. Per foot, it brought about $1,200 more than 645 Willoughby Way. In total dollars, the two closed within $750,000 of each other. A buyer choosing between a new 7,200-square-foot house and a 9,170-square-foot house from 1984 paid nearly the same total either way. The newer house gave up roughly 2,000 square feet of frame to deliver finished construction with no work left to do.
Where Asking Prices and Closings Parted in 2026
Red Mountain's 2026 trades closed in a slower market. In the first half of 2026, Aspen home sales fell 32% from a year earlier and sales at $10 million or more fell 42.6%, The Wall Street Journal reported. The Aspen Times linked weak first-quarter closings partly to a record-low-snow winter. It also reported that sellers generally had the means to wait rather than cut prices sharply, and that 65% to 70% of transactions were cash.
The history of 645 Willoughby Way shows where that patience ran out. It was listed at $23.5 million in 2019 and came back to market in 2025 at $54.9 million. After several price reductions it went under contract in April 2026 at an asking price of $39.6 million and closed at $37 million. Lex Tarumianz of Aspen Snowmass Sotheby's International Realty represented the listing. He told Mansion Global that the sale "reinforces that Willoughby Way is the premier neighborhood in Aspen and one of the highest-end micro-markets in the world." The final price came in about 93% of the April asking price and about two-thirds of the 2025 asking price. The 2025 ask had valued the house as if it were new. The 2026 close valued it as a lot plus a frame.
The new spec home took a smaller discount. It was listed at $45 million while still under construction, completed in March 2025, went under contract in August and sold for $37.75 million, about 84% of its original asking price. Across Aspen, single-family sellers achieved 92% of original list price on average from January through September 2026, and homes averaged 215 days on market, up from 146 a year earlier. Red Mountain homes averaged 166 days on market in the same Q3 2026 report, up from 152 the month before. Sales above $30 million across Aspen numbered seven through September 2026, compared with 10 at the same point in 2025.
Pricing an Older House on Red Mountain
For a buyer comparing a 1980s house on Red Mountain with a newer home elsewhere in Aspen, the 2025 and 2026 trades break the price into parts that can be weighed one at a time.
Start with what the lot would bring empty. The $25 million paid for 848 Willoughby Way in 2024 is the clearest recent marker, and it came after six years of appreciation on the same parcel. Size comes next, because the spread between $37 million and $91.3 million in 2026 came with 4,230 more square feet of house as well as a newer one. Last is the cost and time needed to bring an older house up to the standard of a new build, a calculation that led RH and Mark Hunt to sell rather than build in 2025. In December 2024, by Pitkin County records cited in The Aspen Local, Willoughby Way alone had 13 active building permits and nine demolition permits, about a quarter of its 46 properties. Other owners on the street were weighing the same calculation.
A seller can run the same parts in reverse. Five years of trades show buyers paying fully for land and frame, and the 2026 closings show them discounting asking prices that treated an older house as finished new construction. Our Red Mountain neighborhood page and earlier note on pricing strategy for Red Mountain sellers cover the listing side. Owners weighing a gut renovation against a sale can start with our build and renovation resources.
If you own or are considering a Red Mountain property and want to know what its lot, its frame and its condition each contribute to value, Lex Tarumianz Realty can walk you through the comparable trades behind those figures, including the 645 Willoughby Way sale our team represented this year. Request a Confidential Consultation.